They’re crazy, right? Or maybe they have a “personality disorder.” Our current political season is raising the issue about how wise it is for commentators and the rest of us to put labels on politicians we don’t like in terms of their mental health.
Susan Molchan, a psychiatrist in the Washington, D.C.-area, provides a thought-provoking commentary on this topic at Healthnewsreview.org, the excellent watchdog site for hype and misinformation about health-related matters. She argues that, barring a careful, expert, and actual diagnosis of a patient, it can be destructive to the public dialogue and stigmatizing to those with true mental health afflictions, for the media, in particular, to speculate about public figures’ mental disorder.
Many of these pieces, of course, focus on a polarizing current candidate−and she provides examples of his coverage with commentators’ theorizing. Others could be added, such as: this column in which its author analogizes her own negative health experiences on to the candidate; or this piece−which drew attention because its author also happens to be a psychiatrist.